Blood on the Tracks: Railway Mysteries edited by Martin Edwards (British Library Crime Classics)

I’ve said before that I’m not a big fan of short stories, often finding them disappointing. So I’m glad to say that I enjoyed this anthology edited by Martin Edwards: Blood on the Tracks: Railway Mysteries. Some stories, of course, are better than others.

Blood on the tracks

There are fifteen railway themed stories in the collection and an introduction on classic railway mysteries by Martin Edwards. He has also prefaced each story with a brief biographical note, which I found useful as some of the authors were new to me. I read the collection slowly over a few months, which I find is the best way to approach a short story collection.

Train travel provides several scenarios for a mystery – the restriction of space on trains, with or without a corridor, means that there are a limited number of suspects and they can also provide an ideal place for a ‘locked room’ crime or an ‘impossible crime’ story. This collection also includes a couple of crimes with a supernatural element.

The mysteries are presented in roughly chronological order from 1898 up to  the 1950s. The ones I enjoyed the most are by R Austin Freeman, Roy Vickers, Dorothy L Sayers, F Tennyson Jesse and Freeman Crofts Willis.

  1. The Man with the Watches by Arthur Conan Doyle featuring an un-named sleuth, ‘a well-known criminal investigator’, about a man shot through his heart on the London to Manchester train. He had no ticket on him but had six valuable gold watches in his possession. This was first published in The Strand Magazine in 1898.
  2. The Mystery of Felwyn Tunnel by L T Meade and Robert Eustace. This was also first published in 1898 in which a signalman is found dead at the mouth of the tunnel. When another man dies in in the same place it looks as though something very strange is the cause of their deaths.
  3. How He Cut His Stick by Matthias McDonnell Bodkin. In this story Lady Detective Dora Myrl investigates the theft of £5,000 in gold and notes from a locked railway carriage.
  4. The Mysterious Death on the Underground Railway (1901) by Baroness Orczy, featuring the Old Man in the Corner, an ‘armchair detective’ as he sits in a teashop and tells journalist Polly Burton the solution to the murder of a young woman on the Underground, whilst he fiddles with a piece of string.
  5. The Affair of the Corridor Express by Victor L Whitechurch featuring the railway detective Thorpe Hazell. He investigates the kidnapping of the son of a millionaire.
  6. The Case of Oscar Brodski by R Austin Freeman, an ‘inverted’ detective story, in which the reader knows everything, whereas the detective knows nothing and it all hinges on the significance of trivial details, including fragments of glass, biscuit crumbs, a piece of string and threads of fabric.
  7. The Eighth Lamp by Roy Vickers – an underground mystery about switching off the station lamps after the last train had gone down the line, with a rather spooky supernatural ending.
  8. The Knight’s Cross Signal Problem by Ernest Bramah, in a steam engine crashes into a light train, killing twenty seven people and injuring forty plus. The cause of the accident is a mix up with the signals. I think this is one of the less successful stories for me.
  9. The Unsolved Puzzle of the Man with No Face (1928) by Dorothy L Sayers (a Lord Peter Wimsey story), . The body of a man is found on a lonely beach, his face slashed, and with no means of identification. Wimsey’s discussion of the crime with his fellow passengers as they travel into London, helps D I Winterbottom to solve the mystery – a most intriguing story.
  10. The Railway Carriage by F Tennyson Jesse (1931) – this is possibly my favourite story in the collection. It’s a supernatural mystery in which Solange Fontaine, a female sleuth with a ‘feeling for evil’ features meets two passengers on a train. Both the elderly woman, dressed in shabby black and the insignificant-looking man in a grey felt hat seem to be locked in their own thoughts and she feels very ill at ease. Then the train crashes. An excellent story.
  11. Mystery of the Slip-Coach by Sapper (1933), the creator of ‘Bulldog’ Drummond – an example of an ‘impossible crime’ in which the clue of a raw egg supplies the solution to the murder – I wasn’t convinced by this story.
  12. The Level Crossing by Freeman Crofts Willis ( 1933) in which a man is found dead, lying near an unmanned railway crossing. A mystery that shows the effects of unforeseen circumstances even on a well planned murder.
  13. The Adventure of the First-class Carriage by Ronald Knox (1947) a Sherlock Holmes pastiche with an ‘impossible crime’ scenario.
  14. Murder on the 7.16 by Michael Innes, a John Appleby mystery in which he investigates a murder in a railway carriage on trestles, not on wheels, as it is part of a film set.
  15. The Coulman Handicap by Michael Gilbert (1950s). I found this rather confusing as the police follow a woman passing on stolen goods as she uses the Underground to give them the slip. I think this is possibly the one story in the collection that failed to hold my interest.

My thanks to the publishers for my review copy via NetGalley.

  • Paperback: 358 pages
  • Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press (3 July 2018) in association with the British Library
  • Language: English
  • ISBN-10: 1464209693
  • ISBN-13: 978-1464209697
  • My rating: 3*

21 thoughts on “Blood on the Tracks: Railway Mysteries edited by Martin Edwards (British Library Crime Classics)

  1. I didn’t know that Dorothy L Sayers wrote short stories, so this book appeals to me on that basis in particular, as well as that lovely cover! And who doesn’t love a good golden age railway mystery!!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I’ve read another one of her short stories in the collection Miraculous Mysteries, and I have Hangman’s Holiday in my TBRs – it’s a collection of short stories. And there are more – listed in Wikipedia for example, so there are plenty to look out for. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you! I guess I never really thought to look – I have always just focused on her novels. Great to know there is a whole new DLS world out there to explore. 😀

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m glad you enjoyed this, Margaret. I think that, in general, I like short stories better than you do, so I was interested in this collection. Nice to see Edwards doing the editing, too; I like his work very much. I’m not surprised that ou found some stories to be better than others; I think that’s often the case with collections.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I also struggle with short stories – I find they just don’t satisfy me enough because they always end sooner than I want them to. Martin Edwards is a really good editor though so I imagine he selected the best for this book

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s often my reaction too – wanting more. Most of the stories in this collection are long enough to satisfy me, fortunately. And none of them made me think -‘is that it???’ 🙂


  4. I would much rather immerse myself in a long book than a collection of short stories, but they are good for reading in waiting rooms or on short journeys. I do like trains in 1930s era books, they take me back to 1970s Essex when we lived there – and they were still using 1930s carriages!

    Liked by 2 people

  5. The Dorothy L. Sayers story was so good it led me to grab the volume of all of her Wimsey short stories I own and read the lot. What a treat. Glad you enjoyed this anthology, my favourites were pretty much the same as yours I think.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I missed this one when it came out, but it sounds like I need to get hold of it! They’re always variable, but I usually find there are enough good stories in them to make them well worth reading, and it sounds like there’s the usual mix of well-known and less-known authors in this one. And I like Martin Edwards’ little mini-bios at the beginning of each story too. And then of course, there’s the cover… 😀

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.