Little Black Lies by Sharon Bolton

You can tell from the title what to expect from this book – lies, black lies, but they’re not little lies, they are whopping great big lies. The story is narrated by three of the main characters, Catrin, Callum and Rachel, all unreliable narrators either self deceptive, delusional or manipulative. They are all damaged characters.

Three years before the story begins Catrin’s two sons died in an accident caused by her then best friend Rachel. She has never got over it; they have haunted her ever since and she has not spoken to Rachel since then, determined to take revenge as the third anniversary of their death approaches. A year after their deaths Fred Harper went missing and was never found, then another boy, Jimmy Brown disappeared. As the story begins yet another boy, Archie West is missing. The nightmare continues with the disappearance of Peter, Rachel’s third and youngest son.

Little Black Lies is set in the Falkland Islands in 1994, twelve years after the war and Sharon Bolton’s descriptions of the islands paint a vivid picture of the isolation, the close knit community and war scarred landscape.

But there are a few things about this book that mean whilst I enjoyed the descriptive writing, the sense of place and the opening section very much I didn’t really like it. I began reading it with high expectations as it has received much praise and I’ve enjoyed everything else by Sharon Bolton that I’ve read. And although I was dismayed when I found it was written in the present tense (which is not my favourite style) I thought it was very promising and read on eagerly.

But when I finished it I gave it 3 stars on Goodreads, rounded up from 2.5 (Goodreads doesn’t have half marks!). I wasn’t keen on the focus on missing/dead children which so many books seem to have had recently. And it was a combination of the present tense and the way the plot descended into more of a farce with several twists and turns, particularly as the book draws to an end, one after the other that I just didn’t think was credible. The final  twist at the end came out of the blue for me, although thinking back it shouldn’t have been such a surprise. But I felt a bit cheated. In fact I’m rather annoyed with myself as I’d totally forgotten FictionFan had reviewed this book and I’d thought then that it was one that didn’t appeal to me – at least I was right!

9 thoughts on “Little Black Lies by Sharon Bolton

  1. I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy it as much as I did, but then we can’t all like the same things, can we? For me the best part was the setting, both the location and the view of the society, which I thought she handles remarkable well. In that it reminded me of her first novel, ‘Sacrifice’, which was set in another isolated community.


  2. I think the only thing that would attract me to this book is the Falklands setting, which must be interesting, and different. But I find missing children plots very hard to cope with, they always make me feel as though I’m being manipulated, rather in the same way that I hate finding the protagonist has a cat or dog because I know that something bad will happen to the animal.

    I wish Goodreads would allow half marks!


  3. Ah, I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy it much either. I think it was the same things about it that bothered both of us from your review. It’s a pity, because she’s such a great storyteller and at the beginning I thought she built up a great atmosphere, but in the end there was more about it that I didn’t enjoy than did. Oh well, hopefully she’ll be back on top form in her next one! And thanks for the link! 🙂


  4. Like Geranium Cat I don’t cope well with tales of missing children that dwell on their suffering and I agree that quite a few books seem to have that in them recently. The reason I haven’t continued with the Simon Serallier books by Susan Hill, for instance, is that book 2 is about a child that’s been abducted. Not for me.

    Sorry you didn’t enjoy this Sharon Bolton standalone. I’ve now finished Now You See Me and will publish my brief review of it tomorrow.

    I too can’t understand why Goodreads can’t organise half marks.


  5. Sorry to hear that this one disappointed you, Margaret. I do like the Falklands setting, but I know just what you mean about plot developments needing to have some credibility. And about the use of the present tense, I’m not overly fond of it, either. The story has to be excellent for me to be OK with its use.


  6. Although I enjoyed this one I can absolutely understand the problems you and FictionFan had with this one.. the author did a fantastic job of bringing the Falkland Islands to those of us who had never visited them though.


  7. I’m sorry to hear this didn’t quite do it for you. Such a shame I have heard good things about this and I was intrigued by the setting, but I’ve never read anything by Sharon Bolton before.


Comments are closed.