A Game For All the Family by Sophie Hannah

I’ve recently finished reading A Game For All the Family by Sophie Hannah, a standalone book, described as ‘ a literary puzzle to unlock the dark side of the mind.’

Publishers’ blurb:

Justine thought she knew who she was, until an anonymous caller seemed to know better…

After escaping London and a career that nearly destroyed her, Justine plans to spend her days doing as little as possible in her beautiful home in Devon.

But soon after the move, her daughter Ellen starts to withdraw when her new best friend, George, is unfairly expelled from school. Justine begs the head teacher to reconsider, only to be told that nobody’s been expelled – there is, and was, no George.

Then the anonymous calls start: a stranger, making threats that suggest she and Justine share a traumatic past and a guilty secret – yet Justine doesn’t recognise her voice. When the caller starts to talk about three graves – two big and one small, to fit a child – Justine fears for her family’s safety.

If the police can’t help, she’ll have to eliminate the danger herself, but first she must work out who she’s supposed to be…

Practically from the start I had my doubts about Justine. Was she an unreliable narrator? Could I believe her story, told in the third person but revealing what was going through her mind? Or was her daughter Ellen right when she told her mother that she was a ‘nutter‘? That sense of distrust pervaded my reading. Obviously something had happened to make Justine give up her job in TV drama production and want to ‘do Nothing’, something traumatic and life-changing – had it affected her mental stability or had it happened because she was mentally unstable? I couldn’t decide.

What I can say is that it’s a book about the truth – just who is telling the truth, just who is who they purport to be, and most of all about identity. Who is real, who is making it all up (well Sophie Hannah, obviously).

It is described as a ‘chilling ‘ novel, but I didn’t find it spine tingling, or scary, because it came over to me as artificial, and contrived. It’s also long-winded and mostly completely unbelievable, which made it lose any sense of tension or suspense. But it is a cleverly complicated plot, with stories within stories, – it’s just not chilling.

As well as the anonymous threatening phone calls, and the head teacher’s denial that George had not been expelled and indeed her insistence that he had never even been at the school, Justine is also puzzled by the story that Ellen is writing for her creative writing homework – a story set in their house about a strange family who had lived there in the past and a murder that had taken place there. Where did Ellen get this story, is it based on fact? Ellen simply won’t tell her. Are the phone calls connected to this story and to George?

Maybe it’s too complicated, because at times I just wished the endless questions that went through Justine’s mind would come to an end. They did of course and by the time I did get to the end I still couldn’t decide whether Ellen was right – is Justine a nutter and as I suspect an unreliable narrator, or not?

I didn’t love this book, but it certainly filled my mind and made me think both whilst I was reading it and for days afterwards – and I like that about a book. If Justine is a reliable narrator and was telling the truth all along then she is still a nutter, because if what she described actually happened at the end of the story it was terrible and she was mentally ill and in that case, definitely a chilling ending. I just can’t decide! It is an extraordinary and weird book.

My thanks to Lovereading for sending me an uncorrected proof copy of this book that has had me puzzling for days. A Game For All the Family is due to be published on 13 August 2015 by Hodder & Stoughton.

9 thoughts on “A Game For All the Family by Sophie Hannah

  1. As you know I did love this for the endless questions and the puzzle about what was true, and what was not. I do understand your ambivalence towards the artificialness of the set-up and I think other readers may well feel the same but for me, I enjoyed the twisty turny journey along with all the weirdness.


    1. Cleo, I expect there will be a mixed reaction. I haven’t read any other books by Sophie Hannah, but I see from the Goodreads reviews of other books that some people love them and others dislike them.

      I’m not at all sure I want to read the new Agatha Christie she’s written – I rarely like prequels or sequels written by a different author. An example is Pemberley by P D James, which was a disappointment for me and I like her books normally.


  2. After two such different reviews (you and Cleo) on consecutive days, I will just have to read it for myself. Little Face is one of the first Sophie Hannah books I read and still my favourite. Truly sinister.


  3. Thanks for your candor, Margaret. I keep hearing about this one, and not 100% sure I’ll read it. But the premise does sound interesting. I know what you mean about stretching the limits of credibility, but I’m glad you found ‘food for thought.’


  4. I have stopped reading Sophie Hannah’s series books because they have begun to feel formulaic and contrived. I was hoping that a break from those might have refreshed an author who used to be one of my favourites, but from what you say this doesn’t appear to be the case. Not one I shall look out for.


Comments are closed.