The Matchmaker of Kenmare by Frank Delaney

The Matchmaker of Kenmare by Frank Delaney turned out to be a mammoth read that took me far longer than I expected. I received my copy, an advanced uncorrected proof – without the lovely cover I’ve shown here – courtesy of Meier, the marketing company. It’s a story of journeys, of love and romance, and of war and mystery. I should have loved it, but I didn’t.

It’s narrated by Ben McCarthy looking back on his life as he tells his story to his children. Set during World War II, Ben, still grieving after the disappearance of his wife Venetia ten  years earlier, is travelling around Ireland collecting folklore and trying to find out what has happened to her. He meets Kate Begley, known as the Matchmaker of Kenmare and they become friends. Ireland was neutral during the war but that didn’t stop Ben and Kate’s involvement, after Kate’s husband Charles Miller, an American soldier is reported killed in action. I found it hard to get interested in the story at the beginning and in fact stopped reading it for a while. It was slow to get going and I had to keep looking back trying to work out what was happening and who was who. It didn’t help that this book follows on from a previous one that I haven’t read, which tells the story of Venetia’s mysterious disappearance.

It gathered pace for a while as Kate and Ben travelled to Europe trying to find Charles, who Kate refuses to believe is dead, and into the war action. And there is plenty of action when they are captured by the Germans, despite their Irish neutrality. Even though the war is coming to an end they are in desperate danger. This is, I think, the best part of the book, full of tension and pace. Neutrality is a theme throughout the book. As Frank Delaney writes in his Author’s Note:

… the word neutrality has many shades. For example official papers, released long after 1945, show that Ireland did, in fact, exploit the war politically and contributed many actions to the Allied cause. As to affairs of the heart, who would ever dare to define where friendship should end and passion begin?

Did Ben eventually find out what happened to Venetia and was Charles really dead? I read on, and on, and on as Kate and Ben continued to search for Charles after the war ended. The section where Kate stands waiting for the troops returning from the war, hoping to find Charles amongst them was very moving. But I became tired of their searches and by the time I came to the section where they are travelling to Lebanon in Kansas, the centre of America, the episode with a giraffe and small pig was almost too much to believe. It had all the trappings of a “tall tale”.

Overall, I did enjoy most of it. The book rambles along with many diversions from the main story, some amusing like Neddy who hires a set of false teeth, ‘a set of tombstone dentures’ to make him more attractive to a prospective wife, but mostly I found them distracting. It has a mythic quality. Ben was taught to view his life as though it were a myth, a legend and there are many hints all the way through of the tragic events that are about to unfold – too many hints, I thought, which meant that there were few if any surprises.  Interspersed with Ben’s narration are excerpts from Kate’s journal and his own journal and yet at times the text read more as an objective rather than a personal narrative.

Here is a book trailer featuring Frank Delaney reading from his book.

I agree with Dorothy in her review at Books and Bicycles, in which she says ‘The book would have worked better if told in a more direct manner, without all the editorializing from the older version of Ben and that it ‘does have its pleasures ‘” as you can imagine, the love triangle that develops between Kate, Ben, and Charles is consistently interesting ‘”unfortunately, the quality of the writing kept interfering with the fun.’

And for a more favourable review see Karen’s post on her Cornflower Books blog – ‘it’s a beautifully pitched, fluent story of charm, humour and some inspired ‘“ and even Homeric ‘“ touches.’

The Matchmaker of Kenmare

  • Hardcover: 416 pages
  • Publisher: Random House USA Inc (1 April 2011)
  • Language English
  • ISBN-10: 1400067847
  • ISBN-13: 978-1400067848
  • Source: free review copy

This is my second book for the Ireland Reading Challenge.

11 thoughts on “The Matchmaker of Kenmare by Frank Delaney

  1. Margaret – Thanks for this thorough and well-done review. The characters sound really interesting and I’m sorry to hear you didn’t like it better than you did. I like historical fiction and mysteries and I might give this a go at some point…


  2. Did you read Venetia Kelly’s Traveling Show, the book that comes before this one? I really liked that one – hoping I like this one more than you did, cause I still have it waiting on my to-review shelf! I added your review to the main challenge page. 🙂


    1. No, I haven’t read that one, Carrie. It would have helped me at the beginning of The Matchmaker if I had. I hope you enjoy it when you get round to reading it.


  3. First of all, it sounds like we should read Venetia Kelly before tackling this one…and while I LOVE the cover and the idea of this journey, if it rambles along too much, I’d probably get frustrated, too.

    I recently read another book that was way too long and rambled too much (Freedom, by Jonathan Franzen).


  4. I’m in love with the cover and title of this book, and fully intend to eventually read it, though based on your review and the other comments I will read its predecessor first. Sometimes I like a good ramble and sometimes not–it’s mostly a matter of mood for me.

    Sounds like you’re glad you’re free to move on!


    1. I was attracted to this book mainly by the summary of it by the publishers, without seeing the beautiful cover – that would have got my attention too. You’re right that I was glad to move on from this book – whilst I was reading it I wanted to go on with it, yet when I put it down (and I had to because it took me so long to read it) I was often reluctant to pick it up again.


  5. Very good review, and we seem to have had the same reaction. I liked reading about the Irish countryside, but this book needed some major revision!


  6. I skimmed your review because I’m still reading it. Sorry you hear you didn’t enjoy it. I’m loving it, but I also loved Venetia Kelly’s Traveling Show. It took me awhile to get involved in the first book because of the digressions, but they’re not bothering me this time around because I know that’s how Ben is as a narrator. And I think Delaney is such a talented storyteller that the digressions are always interesting, even if I wish the story would get to the point more quickly.

    I will link to your review on War Through the Generations, if that’s okay.


  7. Interesting review, Margaret. I have heard some good things about this book, so your review gives me a better idea of what to expect when I pick it up.


Comments are closed.