Ruling Passion by Reginald Hill

Ruling passion

HarperCollins|1993|388 pages|Paperback\ my own copy| 3.5* (rounded up to 4*)

Ruling Passion is Reginald Hill’s third Dalziel and Pascoe novel, first published in 1973, in which Pascoe finds his social life and work uncomfortably brought together by a terrible triple murder. Meanwhile, Dalziel is pressuring him about a string of unsolved burglaries, and as events unfold the two cases keep getting jumbled in his mind.

Peter Pascoe is the main character with Dalziel, his boss playing a minor role. Moving on from the second book where Pascoe had renewed his relationship with Ellie Soper, they are now a couple and friends from their university days, Colin and Rose Hopkins have invited them to stay for a weekend in the country at their cottage in the village of Thornton Lacey. They hadn’t seen them for more than five years and the other guests were also old friends, Timothy Mansfield and Charles Rushworth. (References here to Jane Austen’s Mansfield Park)

However, Peter and Ellie didn’t arrive until the Saturday morning when they found a terrible scene – Timothy and Charles lying on the dining room floor in a pool of blood, dead from wounds caused by a shotgun fired at close range, and Rose was in the back garden lying dead at the base of a sundial in the centre of the lawn, her face pressed into the grass. Colin was nowhere to be seen – and the police, headed by Superintendent Backhouse, immediately assume he is the murderer. Peter for once is faced with being a witness rather than a detective and he doesn’t find it easy. He and Ellie are both convinced that Colin didn’t commit the murders – it’s a matter of finding him and proving Backhouse wrong.

As in the previous book, An Advancement of Learning, the plot is by no means straight forward and I found it rather confusing for a while, trying to remember who was who and where they fitted into the mystery. It’s not helped by the fact that the action moves between Thornton Lacey, Yorkshire and Scotland. It wasn’t only Peter who muddled the murder mystery with his unsolved burglaries – I did too. But it all became much clearer towards the end of the book as the connections between the storylines were made.

It’s the main characters though that interested me most and the development of their characters – Peter and Ellie in particular. Their relationship has moved on and during the course of the book they realise how deep their feelings for each other are – leading them into considering getting married. Peter recognises that he can be a very solitary man:

Solitariness was not far from loneliness and this he feared. He believed he could recognize similar characteristics in Ellie, but how good a basis for marriage this common area would be he could not speculate. Equally far from contemplation, however, was a life without Ellie. Which is as good a definition of love as I’m likely to get in a police station, he told himself. Motives for marriage are at least as varied and unexpected as motives for murder. That sounded like the kind of cold comfort Dalziel would doubtless offer! (page 325)

Whereas Peter and Ellie have now become more developed characters Dalziel still remains more of a caricature, rude, coarse and insensitive. But as Ellie gets to know him more so he becomes more human – and more likeable, with more understanding than she had previously thought. By the end of the book Peter, having passed his exams, is promoted to Inspector.

Reginald Hill wrote 24 Dalziel and Pascoe novels. I’ve now read the first and the last and some in between. Currently I’m reading my way through the rest of them – so book 4 is next on my list – An April Shroud.

12 thoughts on “Ruling Passion by Reginald Hill

  1. Coincidentally I watched the BBC version of this last night which, although it sticks to the crime issues fairly well, alters the relationship between Pascoe and Ellie, who are now married and very close to having their first child, who is then called Rose in remembrance. It took some time to see how the two plots were going to come together in an hour and a half of television so I can imagine it would be even more difficult over a longer reading time.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is a coincidence! I always wonder why they feel it necessary to alter the details like that, although I can understand that they need to adapt it for filming. It just jars.


  2. I think one of the things I like best about this series, Margaret, is the depth of character development. I really like the way Hill’s characters evolve over time, and you see it in this novel, in my opinion. And, as you say, the plot is complex without being so convoluted as to distract. I’m glad you enjoyed this one.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I think one of the things I like best about this series, Margaret, is the depth of character development. I really like the way Hill’s characters evolve over time, and you see it in this novel, in my opinion. And, as you say, the plot is complex without being so convoluted as to distract. I’m glad you enjoyed this one.


  4. I haven’t started this series yet, but definitely mean to. I seem to remember FictionFan saying that some of the later books are better, so perhaps I will start there. To be honest, I doubt I am going to make my way through all 24 books in the series.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. These early ones are interesting for the character development but they’re not as good as the later ones. I tend to find the plots let them down a bit. But I do like seeing how Dalziel especially changes and deepens as a character as we get to know him better. Well done for picking up the Austen references – I always miss them!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve probably missed other references 🙂 I think Hill must have liked Jane Austen’s books! Dalziel’s character has certainly got more depth in the later books – it’s interesting to see how he has changed from the first book.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.